Copyright, 1921

BY J. L. W. HENNEY, FOR THE STATE OF OHIO

ๆ

JUDGES OF THE

SUPREME COURT OF OHIO

For the time commencing January 1, 1920, and ending
June 18, 1920.

HON. HUGH L. NICHOLS, CHIEF JUSTICE.

HON. THOMAS A. JONES,

HON. EDWARD S. MATTHIAS,

HON. JAMES G. JOHNSON,

HON. R. M. WANAMAKER,

HON. JAMES E. ROBINSON,

HON. STANLEY W. MERRELL,'

JUDGES.

For the time commencing June 18, 1920, and ending

For the time commencing December 7, 1920, and continuing through

the period of this volume, ending December 31, 1920.

HON. HUGH L. NICHOLS, CHIEF JUSTICE.

'Resigned, effective June 18, 1920.

Appointed by Governor James M. Cox, June 16, 1920, and assumed office June 18, 1920, vice Judge Stanley W. Merrell, resigned. * Elected November 2, 1920, for term ending December 31, 1922, and assumed office December 7, 1920.

ATTORNEY GENERAL,

HON. JOHN G. PRICE.

CLERK,

FRANK E. McKEAN,
W. C. LAWRENCE.

MARSHAL AND LAW LIBRARIAN,

EDWARD ANTRIM,
JOHN W. SHAW.

REPORTER,

J. L. W. HENNEY.

ASSISTANT REPORTERS,
CLINTON COLLINS,
H. L. CONNETT.

Assumed office May 1, 1920. 6 Assumed office May 1, 1920.

(iv)

JUDGES BY WHOM THE OPINIONS IN

THIS VOLUME WERE WRITTEN.

MR. JONES, Judge-

Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Ry. Co. et al. v.
Mills Brothers ...

Cleveland Railway Co. v. Trendel, etc. (dissenting)

Higbee Co. v. Jackson, etc. (dissenting)...

State, ex rel. European Accident Ins. Co., v. Tomlinson,

Supt. of Ins.

PAGE

173

321

.....

93

459,

275

65

State, ex rel. Voight, Jr., v. Lueders, Probate Judge..

Underwood et al. v. Rutan et al......

... 211

306

22

State, ex rel. Keyser, v. Babst..

State, ex rel. Spaulding, v. Baldwin.....

Wegener v. Wegener...

MR. MATTHIAS, Judge-

Dayton & Troy Electric Ry. Co. v. Scott, Treas., et al..... 13
Kinsinger, etc., v. Board of Education of DeGraff Village

School District et al.......

298

Meckley, Auditor, et al. v. Kunzie, Treasurer..

494

Shinnick, etc., et al. v. State, ex rel. Bowers..

246

State, ex rel. City of Toledo, v. Weiler et al., Commission

of Publicity and Efficiency..

123

MR. JOHNSON, Judge-

City of Cincinnati et al. v. Harth, a Taxpayer..

City of Sandusky v. Baltimore & Ohio Ry. Co. et al...... 225

Cleveland Railway Co. v. Trendel, etc.

316

Jackson v. State of Ohio......

152

McClelland, Gdn., et al. v. State, on Application of Clark

et al.

42