 You must look at it not with a view to the question whether, abstractedly, that quantity of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to a person living in the town of Shields...  The New York Supplement - Page 4321909Full view - About this book
 | Great Britain. Court of King's Bench, William Mawdesley Best, George James Philip Smith - 1866 - 702 pages
...proved incontestibly that smoke did come, and in some degree interfered with a certain person, but I said, "You must look at it, not with a view to the...smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to the person living in the town of Shields," because if it only added in an infinitesimal degree to the... | |
 | 1866 - 1190 pages
...interfered with a certain person ; but I said you must look at it now with a view to the question, not whether abstractedly that quantity of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to the person living in the town of Shields, because, if it only added, and in an infinitesimal degree,... | |
 | 1868 - 894 pages
...discomfort from the trade carried on in that shop." Lord CRANWOR.TII, in the same case, puts it thus: — "You must look at it, not with a view to the question whether abstractly that quantity of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to the person Imng... | |
 | Melville Madison Bigelow - 1875 - 830 pages
...proved incontestably that smoke did come and in some degree interfere with a certain pei-son ; but I said, " You must look at it, not with a view to the question whether, abstractly, that quantity of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to a person living... | |
 | Horace Gay Wood - 1875 - 976 pages
...proved incontestibly that smoke did come, and in some degree interfered with a certain person, but I said, ' you must look at it, not with a view to the question whether, abstractly, that quantity of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to the person living... | |
 | Austin Abbott - 1872 - 620 pages
...referred to as having been given by him in a former case, viz : that the jury were not to consider " whether abstractedly, that quantity of smoke was a...nuisance to a person living in the town of Shields," has not been subjected to criticism. Mulligan t>. Elias. between the extreme cases, it is to be observed... | |
 | Sir Arthur Underhill - 1878 - 370 pages
...proved incontestably that smoke did come, and in some degree interfere with a certain person ; but I said, ' You must look at it, not with a view to the...nuisance to a person living in the town of Shields.' " Coming to the Nuisance. Sub-rule 2. — It is no answer to an action for nuisance that the plaintiff... | |
 | 1893 - 2192 pages
...carried on in that shop." Lord Chancellor Westbury in Smelting Co. v. Tipping, 11 HL Cas. 642, 650. "You must look at it, not with a view to the question...nuisance to a person living in the town of Shields," says Lord Cranworth in the same case. "The properties of the plaintiff and defendant lie adjoining... | |
 | 1883 - 908 pages
...individually there may arise much discomfort from the trade carried on in that shop. And Lord CRANWORTH also said : " You must look at it, not with a view to the question whether abstractly that kind of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to a person living in the... | |
 | Robert Stewart Morrison - 1887 - 780 pages
...proved incoutestably that smoke did come and in some degree interfere with a certain person ; but I said, " you must look at it, not with a view to the question whether, abstractly, that quantity of smoke was a nuisance, but whether it was a nuisance to a person living... | |
| |
